So while the advice I received of making one or two large goals, three to five medium goals, and lots of small goals, I've realized it's not properly motivating me.

I'm going to try a new system in a few days (as soon as my apartment's internet starts working).  I'll be making five large goals overall in five areas of my life:

1) Health/Fitness

2) Relationships

3) Skills/Personal Growth

4) Wealth/Career

5) Enjoyment

And hey, if this system doesn't work, I'll just go back to the big --> med --> small system and iron out the kinks.

I got this idea from the Personal MBA program I'm currently working on.  In a few days, I'll enter those goals and roll together my current ones. Let's see what happens.